We have received another 6 reviews from different sectors and from 2 in the
US, 2 in the UK, 1 in the NL, and 1 from AU. I think we have a very good
cross-section of perspectives, including additions of 3 lawyers, a Creative
Commons executive, a science funding agency rep, and another publisher.
Attached for our discussion this Friday at the regular time are all the
summary comments we received and DRAFT responses. The summary reviews and
responses are 33 pages, so we will break up the discussion of the reviews
into the summary and then the specific comments and actual changes to the
Principles and Implementation Guidelines. I believe that the summary
comments will take two phone calls to complete, and we can then discuss the
more specific comments and actual changes to the documents. This is the
same process we followed in the first set of reviews.
The changes to the documents themselves will not be changed as extensively
as the first time, but there are more comments than before because we have
19 reviewers. Please read the attached summary and the instructions at the
top of the document, and be prepared to discuss the responses (but only the
ones you have questions about or disagree with).
Phase 1 of the second round of reviews
You are here